Niyazi Berkes ve Şerif Mardin'in Modernleşme Anlayışlarının Karşılaştırılması
![](/xmlui/themes/Mirage2//images/mime2.png)
View/ Open
Date
2023-05Author
Baltu, Onur
xmlui.dri2xhtml.METS-1.0.item-emb
Acik erisimxmlui.mirage2.itemSummaryView.MetaData
Show full item recordAbstract
Modernization has been a contentious topic that sociologists have devoted time to from
classical sociological theories to contemporary sociological theories. It encompasses deep
economic, political, social, and cultural changes that have occurred from the Ottoman
Empire to the Republic of Turkey. Niyazi Berkes and Şerif Mardin are two significant
thinkers who have addressed the transformations and changes in Turkish social life.
This study aims to examine the process of Turkish modernization/contemporization by
Niyazi Berkes and Şerif Mardin within the framework of their contextual perspectives.
The study includes the biographies of the relevant thinkers, the sociological trends of their
time, and the historical transformations related to Turkish modernization. The conclusion
focuses on the similarities and differences between the thinkers.
Drawing on Charles Taylor's theory of "Two Types of Modernity," the study categorizes
Niyazi Berkes as a culturalist and Şerif Mardin as an acculturalist. The objective is to
provide a detailed and comprehensive analysis of the thinkers' knowledge on
modernization/contemporization.
Niyazi Berkes examines the changes Turkey has undergone in the past two centuries
through a historical sociological lens. He approaches the process of modernization in a
positivist context, discussing how societies constantly progress and transform based on
social and economic indicators. Berkes places Europe at the center of modernization,
suggesting that non-Western countries would progress by establishing a resemblance with
the West. Consequently, it can be said that Berkes holds a culturalist approach.
On the other hand, Şerif Mardin is another Turkish sociologist who, like Berkes, examines
the changes that have taken place over two centuries. Mardin refers to technical and
structural changes in his analysis of the modernization process. He adopts a hermeneutic
approach, utilizing various methodological elements in his work, as he believes that
approaching events from a macro perspective may lead to generalization errors. Mardin
employs the center-periphery theory in his interpretation of modernization, presenting a
separate analysis of the center and periphery through micro-examples. He believes that
modernization differs from country to country, which positions Mardin as a culturalist
thinker.